Left

CivilFEM Online Help

Official Websites: CivilFEM | CivilFEM Licenses | Ingeciber | Current downloads
CivilFEM for Ansys: Install | Doc | Verif | Instala | Doc(ES) | PDF | PDF(ES) | Support | Soporte | Class3
CivilFEM Apps for Ansys Workbench: Install | Lic | FAQ | Concrete | Steel | Theory | PDF | Support | Soporte | Class3
CivilFEM powered by Marc: Install | Capabilities | Cap(ES) | Doc | Python | Theory | Verif | PDF | Support | Soporte | Class3
Right

CFVR2958 - Shell shear check according to SP63133 (compression & tension)

Check Shear plus axial force of a reinforced concrete shell according to SP63133

Element types used in the model: SHELL_181

Needed CivilFEM Modules:
Geotechnical Module
Bridges and Civil Non Linearities Module
Advanced Prestressed Concrete Module

The example can be launched on an educational license.
KEYWORDS
Shell
Shell Vertex
Reinforced Concrete
Shear check
SP63133

Model Statistics
Number of elements 18
Number of nodes 28
Number of civil materials 2
Number of cross sections 0
Number of shell vertices 1

Log file: CFVR2958.DAT


   FINISH
  ~CFCLEAR,,1
   NomFile='CFVR2958'
  /TITLE, %NomFile%, Shell shear check with SP63133 (compression & tension)

! ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
! Model definition and solve
! ------------------------------------------------------------------------------

! Parameters
   A = 3
   B = 6
   T = 0.2         ! Thickness
   R = 0.03        ! Cover 
   AST = 3.0708e-3
   ASB = 6.296e-3
   EsIZ = 1
   S =0.1
   ASW = 0.00022831/S

   
! Code
~CODESEL,,SP63133,

! Units
 ~UNITS,,FORC,KN 
  
/PREP7
! Material
~CFMP,1,LIB,CONCRETE,SP63133,B25
~CFMP,2,LIB,REINF,SP63133,A400  
~CFMP,1,SP_C    ,GAMb    ,,18.5/14.5
~CFMP,1,SP_C    ,GAMbt   ,,1.55/1.05
  
! Element types
ET,1,181
KEYOPT,1,3,2
KEYOPT,1,8,2
   
! Shell Vertex 
~SHLRNF,1,T,1,2,R,AST,ASB,AST,ASB,0,0.000,45.00
~SHLSHR,1,2,,,,,,,ASW,ASW 

! Shell properties
~BMSHPRO,1,SHELL,1,1,1,1, 181,,, ,Shell 1   
  
! Geometry
RECTNG,0,A,0,B
  
! Mesh
AESIZE,1,EsIZ,  
AMESH,1
  
FINISH
/SOLU 
 
! BCs
NSEL,S,LOC,X,0
NSEL,A,LOC,X,A
D,ALL,UX  
NSEL,S,LOC,Y,0
D,ALL, , , , , ,UX,UY,UZ,ROTZ, ,   
NSEL,S,LOC,Y,B
D,ALL, , , , , ,UX,UZ,ROTZ, , ,
ALLSEL
  
! CASE 1: COMPRESSION 1
Q = 60
H = 100

! Vertical Pressure
!SFE,ALL,1,PRES, ,-Q

! Compression pressure to forces
!NSEL,S,LOC,Y,B
!*GET,NNODE,NODE,,COUNT
!F,ALL,FY,-H*A/NNODE

ALLSEL
SOLVE		! CASE 1

FDELE,ALL,ALL
SFEDELE,ALL,ALL,ALL

! CASE 2: COMPRESSION 2
Q = 60
H = 2000

! Vertical Pressure
!SFE,ALL,1,PRES, ,-Q

! Compression pressure to forces
! NSEL,S,LOC,Y,B
! *GET,NNODE,NODE,,COUNT
! F,ALL,FY,-H*A/NNODE

ALLSEL
SOLVE		! CASE 2

FDELE,ALL,ALL
SFEDELE,ALL,ALL,ALL

! CASE 3:  COMPRESSION
Q = 60
H = 2320

! Vertical Pressure
! SFE,ALL,1,PRES, ,-Q

! Compression pressure to forces
! NSEL,S,LOC,Y,B
! *GET,NNODE,NODE,,COUNT
! F,ALL,FY,-H*A/NNODE

ALLSEL
SOLVE		! CASE 3

FDELE,ALL,ALL
SFEDELE,ALL,ALL,ALL

! CASE 4:  TENSION
Q = 60
H = 200

! Vertical Pressure
! SFE,ALL,1,PRES, ,-Q

! Compression pressure to forces
! NSEL,S,LOC,Y,B
! *GET,NNODE,NODE,,COUNT
! F,ALL,FY,H*A/NNODE

ALLSEL
SOLVE		! CASE 4

FDELE,ALL,ALL
SFEDELE,ALL,ALL,ALL


FINISH
/POST1

! CASE 1
~CFSET,,1

ESEL,S, , ,     15  ! Lateral endside element
~FMREAD,CFVR2958,FM 
~CHKCON,SHELL,SHEAR

! CASE 2
~CFSET,,2

ESEL,S, , ,     16  ! Lateral endside element
~FMREAD,CFVR2958,FM 
~CHKCON,SHELL,SHEAR

! CASE 3
~CFSET,,3

ESEL,S, , ,     17  ! Lateral endside element
~FMREAD,CFVR2958,FM 
~CHKCON,SHELL,SHEAR

! CASE 4
~CFSET,,4

ESEL,S, , ,     18  ! Lateral endside element
~FMREAD,CFVR2958,FM 
~CHKCON,SHELL,SHEAR
 
!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
! DATA CHECK
!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
! Data comparison number
  NComp = 68
  NComp_ch = 0

! Matrix dim.
  *DIM,LABEL,CHAR,Ncomp,1
  *DIM,LABEL_CH,CHAR,Ncomp_ch,1
  *DIM,VALUE,,Ncomp,3
  *DIM,VALUE_CH,CHAR,Ncomp_ch,3
  *DIM,TOLER,,Ncomp,2

! Labels
!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
! CASE 1 CHECK
  LABEL(1 ) = 'C1_Q1_X'
  LABEL(2 ) = 'C1_CRTQ1_X'
  LABEL(3 ) = 'C1_QB_X'
  LABEL(4 ) = 'C1_QSW_X'
  LABEL(5 ) = 'C1_Q2_X'
  LABEL(6 ) = 'C1_CRTQ2_X'
  LABEL(7 ) = 'C1_CRT_TOTX'
  LABEL(8 ) = 'C1_PHI_N_X'
  LABEL(9 ) = 'C1_Q1_Y'
  LABEL(10) = 'C1_CRTQ1_Y'
  LABEL(11) = 'C1_QB_Y'
  LABEL(12) = 'C1_QSW_Y'
  LABEL(13) = 'C1_Q2_Y'
  LABEL(14) = 'C1_CRTQ2_Y'
  LABEL(15) = 'C1_CRT_TOTY'
  LABEL(16) = 'C1_PHI_N_Y'
  LABEL(17) = 'C1_CRT_TOT'
 
  
! CASE 2 CHECK
  LABEL(18) = 'C2_Q1_X'
  LABEL(19) = 'C2_CRTQ1_X'
  LABEL(20) = 'C2_QB_X'
  LABEL(21) = 'C2_QSW_X'
  LABEL(22) = 'C2_Q2_X'
  LABEL(23) = 'C2_CRTQ2_X'
  LABEL(24) = 'C2_CRT_TOTX'
  LABEL(25) = 'C2_PHI_N_X'
  LABEL(26) = 'C2_Q1_Y'
  LABEL(27) = 'C2_CRTQ1_Y'
  LABEL(28) = 'C2_QB_Y'
  LABEL(29) = 'C2_QSW_Y'
  LABEL(30) = 'C2_Q2_Y'
  LABEL(31) = 'C2_CRTQ2_Y'
  LABEL(32) = 'C2_CRT_TOTY'
  LABEL(33) = 'C2_PHI_N_Y'
  LABEL(34) = 'C2_CRT_TOT'
  
! CASE 3 check
  LABEL(35) = 'C3_Q1_X'
  LABEL(36) = 'C3_CRTQ1_X'
  LABEL(37) = 'C3_QB_X'
  LABEL(38) = 'C3_QSW_X'
  LABEL(39) = 'C3_Q2_X'
  LABEL(40) = 'C3_CRTQ2_X'
  LABEL(41) = 'C3_CRT_TOTX'
  LABEL(42) = 'C3_PHI_N_X'
  LABEL(43) = 'C3_Q1_Y'
  LABEL(44) = 'C3_CRTQ1_Y'
  LABEL(45) = 'C3_QB_Y'
  LABEL(46) = 'C3_QSW_Y'
  LABEL(47) = 'C3_Q2_Y'
  LABEL(48) = 'C3_CRTQ2_Y'
  LABEL(49) = 'C3_CRT_TOTY'
  LABEL(50) = 'C3_PHI_N_Y'
  LABEL(51) = 'C3_CRT_TOT'
  
! CASE 3 check
  LABEL(52) = 'C4_Q1_X'
  LABEL(53) = 'C4_CRTQ1_X'
  LABEL(54) = 'C4_QB_X'
  LABEL(55) = 'C4_QSW_X'
  LABEL(56) = 'C4_Q2_X'
  LABEL(57) = 'C4_CRTQ2_X'
  LABEL(58) = 'C4_CRT_TOTX'
  LABEL(59) = 'C4_PHI_N_X'
  LABEL(60) = 'C4_Q1_Y'
  LABEL(61) = 'C4_CRTQ1_Y'
  LABEL(62) = 'C4_QB_Y'
  LABEL(63) = 'C4_QSW_Y'
  LABEL(64) = 'C4_Q2_Y'
  LABEL(65) = 'C4_CRTQ2_Y'
  LABEL(66) = 'C4_CRT_TOTY'
  LABEL(67) = 'C4_PHI_N_Y'
  LABEL(68) = 'C4_CRT_TOT'
  

! Correct values
! CASE 1 CHECK
  VALUE(1 ,1)= 744.677
  VALUE(2 ,1)= 204.4/VALUE(1 ,1)
  VALUE(3 ,1)= 89.250
  VALUE(4 ,1)= 108
  VALUE(5 ,1)= 198.63
  VALUE(6 ,1)= 204.4/VALUE(5 ,1)
  VALUE(7 ,1)= MAX(VALUE(2 ,1),VALUE(6 ,1)) ! max CRTQ1_X,CRTQ2_X
  VALUE(8 ,1)= 1.007
  VALUE(9 ,1)= 764.64
  VALUE(10,1)= 394.5/VALUE(9 ,1)
  VALUE(11,1)= 89.250
  VALUE(12,1)= 108
  VALUE(13,1)= 203.96
  VALUE(14,1)= 394.5/VALUE(13,1)
  VALUE(15,1)= MAX(VALUE(10 ,1),VALUE(14 ,1)) ! max CRTQ1_Y,CRTQ2_Y
  VALUE(16,1)= 1.034
  VALUE(17,1)= VALUE(7 ,1) + VALUE(15,1)
  
! CASE 2 CHECK
  VALUE(18,1)= 841.551
  VALUE(19,1)= 204.4/VALUE(18 ,1)
  VALUE(20,1)= 89.250
  VALUE(21,1)= 108
  VALUE(22,1)= 224.472
  VALUE(23,1)= 204.4/VALUE(22 ,1)
  VALUE(24,1)= MAX(VALUE(19 ,1),VALUE(23 ,1)) ! max CRTQ1_X,CRTQ2_X
  VALUE(25,1)= 1.138
  VALUE(26,1)= 924.375
  VALUE(27,1)= 394.5/VALUE(26 ,1)
  VALUE(28,1)= 89.250
  VALUE(29,1)= 108
  VALUE(30,1)= 246.564
  VALUE(31,1)= 394.5/VALUE(30,1)
  VALUE(32,1)= MAX(VALUE(27 ,1),VALUE(31 ,1)) ! max CRTQ1_Y,CRTQ2_Y
  VALUE(33,1)= 1.25
  VALUE(34,1)= VALUE(24 ,1)+VALUE(32,1)
  
! CASE 3
  VALUE(35,1)= 857.8
  VALUE(36,1)= 204.4/VALUE(35 ,1)
  VALUE(37,1)= 89.250
  VALUE(38,1)= 108
  VALUE(39,1)= 228.8
  VALUE(40,1)= 204.4/VALUE(39 ,1)
  VALUE(41,1)= MAX(VALUE(36 ,1),VALUE(40 ,1)) ! max CRTQ1_X,CRTQ2_X
  VALUE(42,1)= 1.16
  VALUE(43,1)= 739.5
  VALUE(44,1)= 394.5/VALUE(43 ,1)
  VALUE(45,1)= 89.250
  VALUE(46,1)= 108
  VALUE(47,1)= 197.25    ! 
  VALUE(48,1)= 394.5/VALUE(47,1)
  VALUE(49,1)= MAX(VALUE(44 ,1),VALUE(48 ,1)) ! max CRTQ1_Y,CRTQ2_Y
  VALUE(50,1)= 1.0
  VALUE(51,1)= VALUE(41 ,1)+VALUE(49,1)
  
! CASE 4
  VALUE(52,1)= 369.750
  VALUE(53,1)= 204.4/VALUE(52 ,1)
  VALUE(54,1)= 89.250
  VALUE(55,1)= 108
  VALUE(56,1)= 98.625
  VALUE(57,1)= 204.4/VALUE(56 ,1)
  VALUE(58,1)= MAX(VALUE(53 ,1),VALUE(57 ,1)) ! max CRTQ1_X,CRTQ2_X
  VALUE(59,1)= 0.5
  VALUE(60,1)= 387
  VALUE(61,1)= 394.5/VALUE(60 ,1)
  VALUE(62,1)= 89.250
  VALUE(63,1)= 108
  VALUE(64,1)= 103.360    ! 
  VALUE(65,1)= 394.5/VALUE(64,1)
  VALUE(66,1)= MAX(VALUE(61 ,1),VALUE(65 ,1)) ! max CRTQ1_Y,CRTQ2_Y
  VALUE(67,1)= 0.524
  VALUE(68,1)= VALUE(58 ,1)+VALUE(66,1)
  
 
! Comparison
 ~CFSET,1
 ~CFGET,VALUE(1 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,Q1_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(2 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,CRTQ1_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(3 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,QB_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(4 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,QSW_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(5 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,Q2_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(6 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,CRTQ2_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(7 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,CRT_TOTX,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(8 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,PHI_N_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(9 ,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,Q1_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(10,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,CRTQ1_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(11,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,QB_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(12,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,QSW_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(13,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,Q2_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(14,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,CRTQ2_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(15,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,CRT_TOTY,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(16,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,PHI_N_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(17,2),ELEMENT,15,RESULT,CRT_TOT,I
 
 
 ~CFSET,2
 ~CFGET,VALUE(18,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,Q1_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(19,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,CRTQ1_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(20,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,QB_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(21,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,QSW_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(22,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,Q2_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(23,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,CRTQ2_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(24,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,CRT_TOTX,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(25,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,PHI_N_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(26,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,Q1_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(27,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,CRTQ1_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(28,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,QB_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(29,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,QSW_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(30,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,Q2_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(31,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,CRTQ2_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(32,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,CRT_TOTY,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(33,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,PHI_N_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(34,2),ELEMENT,16,RESULT,CRT_TOT,I
 
 ~CFSET,3
 ~CFGET,VALUE(35,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,Q1_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(36,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,CRTQ1_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(37,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,QB_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(38,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,QSW_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(39,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,Q2_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(40,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,CRTQ2_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(41,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,CRT_TOTX,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(42,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,PHI_N_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(43,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,Q1_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(44,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,CRTQ1_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(45,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,QB_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(46,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,QSW_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(47,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,Q2_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(48,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,CRTQ2_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(49,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,CRT_TOTY,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(50,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,PHI_N_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(51,2),ELEMENT,17,RESULT,CRT_TOT,I
 
 ~CFSET,4
 ~CFGET,VALUE(52,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,Q1_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(53,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,CRTQ1_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(54,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,QB_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(55,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,QSW_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(56,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,Q2_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(57,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,CRTQ2_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(58,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,CRT_TOTX,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(59,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,PHI_N_X,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(60,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,Q1_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(61,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,CRTQ1_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(62,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,QB_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(63,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,QSW_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(64,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,Q2_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(65,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,CRTQ2_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(66,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,CRT_TOTY,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(67,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,PHI_N_Y,I
 ~CFGET,VALUE(68,2),ELEMENT,18,RESULT,CRT_TOT,I
 

! Warning and error tolerances
! CASE 1 CHECK
TOLER(1 ,1)= VALUE(1 ,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER( 1,2)=VALUE(1 ,1)*2E-2 
TOLER(2 ,1)= VALUE(2 ,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER( 2,2)=VALUE(2 ,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(3 ,1)= VALUE(3 ,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER( 3,2)=VALUE(3 ,1)*2E-2
TOLER(4 ,1)= VALUE(4 ,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER( 4,2)=VALUE(4 ,1)*1E-2
TOLER(5 ,1)= VALUE(5 ,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER( 5,2)=VALUE(5 ,1)*1E-2
TOLER(6 ,1)= VALUE(6 ,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER( 6,2)=VALUE(6 ,1)*1E-2
TOLER(7 ,1)= VALUE(7 ,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER( 7,2)=VALUE(7 ,1)*1E-2
TOLER(8 ,1)= VALUE(8 ,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER( 8,2)=VALUE(8 ,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(9 ,1)= VALUE(9 ,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER( 9,2)=VALUE(9 ,1)*2E-2 
TOLER(10,1)= VALUE(10,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(10,2)=VALUE(10,1)*1E-2
TOLER(11,1)= VALUE(11,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(11,2)=VALUE(11,1)*2E-2
TOLER(12,1)= VALUE(12,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(12,2)=VALUE(12,1)*1E-2
TOLER(13,1)= VALUE(13,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(13,2)=VALUE(13,1)*1E-2
TOLER(14,1)= VALUE(14,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(14,2)=VALUE(14,1)*1E-2
TOLER(15,1)= VALUE(15,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(15,2)=VALUE(15,1)*1E-2
TOLER(16,1)= VALUE(16,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(16,2)=VALUE(16,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(17,1)= VALUE(17,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(17,2)=VALUE(17,1)*1E-2 


! CASE 2 CHECK
TOLER(18,1)= VALUE(18,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(18,2)=VALUE(18,1)*2E-2 
TOLER(19,1)= VALUE(19,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(19,2)=VALUE(19,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(20,1)= VALUE(20,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(20,2)=VALUE(20,1)*2E-2
TOLER(21,1)= VALUE(21,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(21,2)=VALUE(21,1)*1E-2
TOLER(22,1)= VALUE(22,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(22,2)=VALUE(22,1)*1E-2
TOLER(23,1)= VALUE(23,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(23,2)=VALUE(23,1)*1E-2
TOLER(24,1)= VALUE(24,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(24,2)=VALUE(24,1)*1E-2
TOLER(25,1)= VALUE(25,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(25,2)=VALUE(25,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(26,1)= VALUE(26,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(26,2)=VALUE(26,1)*2E-2 
TOLER(27,1)= VALUE(27,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(27,2)=VALUE(27,1)*1E-2
TOLER(28,1)= VALUE(28,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(28,2)=VALUE(28,1)*2E-2
TOLER(29,1)= VALUE(29,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(29,2)=VALUE(29,1)*1E-2
TOLER(30,1)= VALUE(30,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(30,2)=VALUE(30,1)*1E-2
TOLER(31,1)= VALUE(31,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(31,2)=VALUE(31,1)*1E-2
TOLER(32,1)= VALUE(32,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(32,2)=VALUE(32,1)*1E-2
TOLER(33,1)= VALUE(33,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(33,2)=VALUE(33,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(34,1)= VALUE(34,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(34,2)=VALUE(34,1)*1E-2 


! CASE 3 CHECK
TOLER(35,1)= VALUE(35,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(35,2)=VALUE(35,1)*2E-2 
TOLER(36,1)= VALUE(36,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(36,2)=VALUE(36,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(37,1)= VALUE(37,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(37,2)=VALUE(37,1)*2E-2
TOLER(38,1)= VALUE(38,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(38,2)=VALUE(38,1)*1E-2
TOLER(39,1)= VALUE(39,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(39,2)=VALUE(39,1)*1E-2
TOLER(40,1)= VALUE(40,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(40,2)=VALUE(40,1)*1E-2
TOLER(41,1)= VALUE(41,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(41,2)=VALUE(41,1)*1E-2
TOLER(42,1)= VALUE(42,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(42,2)=VALUE(42,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(43,1)= VALUE(43,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(43,2)=VALUE(43,1)*2E-2 
TOLER(44,1)= VALUE(44,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(44,2)=VALUE(44,1)*1E-2
TOLER(45,1)= VALUE(45,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(45,2)=VALUE(45,1)*2E-2
TOLER(46,1)= VALUE(46,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(46,2)=VALUE(46,1)*1E-2
TOLER(47,1)= VALUE(47,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(47,2)=VALUE(47,1)*1E-2
TOLER(48,1)= VALUE(48,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(48,2)=VALUE(48,1)*1E-2
TOLER(49,1)= VALUE(49,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(49,2)=VALUE(49,1)*1E-2
TOLER(50,1)= VALUE(50,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(50,2)=VALUE(50,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(51,1)= VALUE(51,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(51,2)=VALUE(51,1)*1E-2 

! CASE 4 CHECK
TOLER(52,1)= VALUE(52,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(52,2)=VALUE(52,1)*2E-2 
TOLER(53,1)= VALUE(53,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(53,2)=VALUE(53,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(54,1)= VALUE(54,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(54,2)=VALUE(54,1)*2E-2
TOLER(55,1)= VALUE(55,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(55,2)=VALUE(55,1)*1E-2
TOLER(56,1)= VALUE(56,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(56,2)=VALUE(56,1)*1E-2
TOLER(57,1)= VALUE(57,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(57,2)=VALUE(57,1)*1E-2
TOLER(58,1)= VALUE(58,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(58,2)=VALUE(58,1)*1E-2
TOLER(59,1)= VALUE(59,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(59,2)=VALUE(59,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(60,1)= VALUE(60,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(60,2)=VALUE(60,1)*2E-2 
TOLER(61,1)= VALUE(61,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(61,2)=VALUE(61,1)*1E-2
TOLER(62,1)= VALUE(62,1)*2E-2 $ TOLER(62,2)=VALUE(62,1)*2E-2
TOLER(63,1)= VALUE(63,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(63,2)=VALUE(63,1)*1E-2
TOLER(64,1)= VALUE(64,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(64,2)=VALUE(64,1)*1E-2
TOLER(65,1)= VALUE(65,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(65,2)=VALUE(65,1)*1E-2
TOLER(66,1)= VALUE(66,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(66,2)=VALUE(66,1)*1E-2
TOLER(67,1)= VALUE(67,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(67,2)=VALUE(67,1)*1E-2 
TOLER(68,1)= VALUE(68,1)*1E-2 $ TOLER(68,2)=VALUE(68,1)*1E-2 


 
!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
! Results comparison
!--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  COMPARA.MAC

Results

LabelTargetCivilFEMRatioTolerance
C1_Q1_X 744.68 744.61.000 14.89
C1_CRTQ1 0.27448 0.274511.0000.002745
C1_QB_X 89.25 89.251.000 1.785
C1_QSW_X 108 1081.000 1.08
C1_Q2_X 198.63 198.611.000 1.986
C1_CRTQ2 1.029 1.02911.000 0.01029
C1_CRT_T 1.029 1.02911.000 0.01029
C1_PHI_N 1.007 1.00691.000 0.01007
C1_Q1_Y 764.64 7651.000 15.29
C1_CRTQ1 0.51593 0.515691.0000.005159
C1_QB_Y 89.25 89.251.000 1.785
C1_QSW_Y 108 1081.000 1.08
C1_Q2_Y 203.96 204.051.000 2.04
C1_CRTQ2 1.9342 1.93331.000 0.01934
C1_CRT_T 1.9342 1.93331.000 0.01934
C1_PHI_N 1.034 1.03451.000 0.01034
C1_CRT_T 2.9633 2.96251.000 0.02963
C2_Q1_X 841.55 841.51.000 16.83
C2_CRTQ1 0.24288 0.24291.0000.002429
C2_QB_X 89.25 89.251.000 1.785
C2_QSW_X 108 1081.000 1.08
C2_Q2_X 224.47 224.461.000 2.245
C2_CRTQ2 0.91058 0.910641.0000.009106
C2_CRT_T 0.91058 0.910641.0000.009106
C2_PHI_N 1.138 1.13791.000 0.01138
C2_Q1_Y 924.38 924.381.000 18.49
C2_CRTQ1 0.42677 0.426771.0000.004268
C2_QB_Y 89.25 89.251.000 1.785
C2_QSW_Y 108 1081.000 1.08
C2_Q2_Y 246.56 246.561.000 2.466
C2_CRTQ2 1.6 1.61.000 0.016
C2_CRT_T 1.6 1.61.000 0.016
C2_PHI_N 1.25 1.251.000 0.0125
C2_CRT_T 2.5106 2.51061.000 0.02511
C3_Q1_X 857.8 857.821.000 17.16
C3_CRTQ1 0.23828 0.238281.0000.002383
C3_QB_X 89.25 89.251.000 1.785
C3_QSW_X 108 1081.000 1.08
C3_Q2_X 228.8 228.811.000 2.288
C3_CRTQ2 0.89336 0.893321.0000.008934
C3_CRT_T 0.89336 0.893321.0000.008934
C3_PHI_N 1.16 1.161.000 0.0116
C3_Q1_Y 739.5 739.51.000 14.79
C3_CRTQ1 0.53347 0.533471.0000.005335
C3_QB_Y 89.25 89.251.000 1.785
C3_QSW_Y 108 1081.000 1.08
C3_Q2_Y 197.25 197.251.000 1.972
C3_CRTQ2 2 21.000 0.02
C3_CRT_T 2 21.000 0.02
C3_PHI_N 1 11.000 0.01
C3_CRT_T 2.8934 2.89331.000 0.02893
C4_Q1_X 369.75 369.751.000 7.395
C4_CRTQ1 0.55281 0.552811.0000.005528
C4_QB_X 89.25 89.251.000 1.785
C4_QSW_X 108 1081.000 1.08
C4_Q2_X 98.625 98.6251.000 0.9862
C4_CRTQ2 2.0725 2.07251.000 0.02072
C4_CRT_T 2.0725 2.07251.000 0.02072
C4_PHI_N 0.5 0.51.000 0.005
C4_Q1_Y 387 387.360.999 7.74
C4_CRTQ1 1.0194 1.01841.001 0.01019
C4_QB_Y 89.25 89.251.000 1.785
C4_QSW_Y 108 1081.000 1.08
C4_Q2_Y 103.36 103.321.000 1.034
C4_CRTQ2 3.8168 3.81821.000 0.03817
C4_CRT_T 3.8168 3.81821.000 0.03817
C4_PHI_N 0.524 0.523811.000 0.00524
C4_CRT_T 5.8893 5.89071.000 0.05889

Contains proprietary and confidential information of Ingeciber, S.A.